Local SEO

Two Google Business Profiles, No Access to One: How We Fixed It

By

One of our clients, a family-owned painting contractor on the East End of Long Island, had two Google Business Profiles. The one customers saw, with his reviews, was managed by a Google account no one at the company could get into. The one he could manage had a single review and wasn't visible to customers.

Fixing it took from July to October 19. Most of that time was waiting, documenting and resisting quick fixes that would have made things worse. Here's what we did at each step, and what I'd tell any business owner in the same spot. I've left out the private details: names, addresses and anything from the company's paperwork.

How a business ends up with two profiles

It's rarely on purpose. Over the years a business changes phone numbers, partners and marketing companies, and each one may create or claim a listing along the way.

When we started cleaning up this client's directory listings with our listings partner, we found profiles already claimed on Google, Facebook, Bing, Yelp and other directories, and the owner didn't have the logins for several of them. The directory cleanup took care of most of those. Google needed more.

The two Google profiles had the same phone number and website, under slightly different versions of the company name. Google's guidelines allow one profile per business, and Google says a profile it flags as a duplicate won't show on Search or Maps.

From two profiles to one
  1. Ownership requestedFrom the owner's own Google account, for the profile with his reviews.
  2. The deadline passesThe next day, Google says the owner can verify to start managing the profile.
  3. Still out of reachThe profile still isn't in the owner's hands, so the address change waits.
  4. Investigate, then contact GoogleEvery Google record listed. A signed authorization letter, and Google support contacted.
  5. One appeal, with evidenceRegistration, license, insurance and a photo of the branded van.
  6. Appeal approvedOne profile, owned by the business, with its reviews.

Step 1: Pick the profile worth keeping, and don't make a third

The tempting fix is to start over with a brand-new profile. That only adds a third record for the same business, and Google's guidelines are clear that there should be one profile per business.

So the first decision was which profile to keep. Not the one the owner could log into, but the one with the real history: the profile customers already knew, with his reviews.

Step 2: Request ownership the official way

In July, from the owner's own Google account, we requested ownership of that profile. Google showed us part of the email address of whoever managed it. We didn't know whose it was.

Google gives the current manager 3 days to respond. If they don't, you may be able to claim the profile yourself, though Google notes that option "isn't always available."

The deadline passed, and the next day Google said the owner could verify to start managing the profile. That should have been the end of it. It wasn't: at the end of August, the profile was still out of his reach.

Step 3: Change one thing at a time

Around the same time, the owner was planning to move. An address change goes through Google's review, can take up to 30 days to show, and may mean verifying the business again. So the advice, from our listings partner and from us, was to wait: recover the profile first, then update the address. When ownership, duplicates and an address all change at once, it's very hard to tell which one Google is reacting to.

The move raised a second question. A painter who works at clients' homes is what Google calls a service-area business. Google says that if you don't serve customers at your business address, you should remove it from your profile and list the towns you serve instead. That change waits its turn too.

Each of these felt urgent. Waiting was the right call.

Step 4: Investigate before touching anything

In September we stopped and investigated. Before changing a single field, we listed every Google record for the business: what each one showed, who could manage it, and what Google's current help pages say about each situation. We marked what was proven and what was only likely. Our private AI research agent helps with this part: it checks Google's current guidance, so we're not working from old rules of thumb.

We also wrote down what we would not do:

  • No new profile.
  • No keywords added to the business name. Google says extra information in a name can get a profile suspended.
  • No changes to the phone number, website or categories just to trigger a new review.
  • No repeated ownership requests from different accounts.
  • No fake storefront, and no documents that aren't real.

The owner signed a letter authorizing us to work with Google on the company's behalf, and we contacted Google support with it.

Step 5: Gather the evidence, then appeal once

The profile the owner could manage had been suspended, so in October we filed an appeal through Google's appeals tool.

Google asks for documents that show the same business name and address as the profile, such as a business registration, a business license or utility bills. We sent:

  • the company's New York State business registration
  • its local contractor license
  • its commercial liability insurance certificate
  • its workers' compensation insurance certificate
  • a photo of the company's branded work van

Each appeal can be submitted only once, and Google says a decision can take up to 5 business days. So check every document against the profile before you send anything.

Evidence to have ready

Tick what you already have. Nothing you tick is saved.

Evidence you already have

Google asks that the business name and address on each document match your profile. Source: Google.

Step 6: The result

On October 19, Google approved the appeal. Today the business has one profile, the owner is its primary owner, and Alchemy Effect is a manager. The reviews stayed with the profile.

That last arrangement is the one I want for every client: the business owns its profile, and its designer or agency is a manager, never the owner.

What we worked on while we waited

Google moves at its own pace, so we kept working on what we could control:

  • We cleaned up the company's directory listings with our listings partner, so its name, phone number and website match across the web.
  • We took over care of the company's website, domain and business email, so the business can show it controls each one.
  • We made a series of improvements to the company's website, which Google also reads when it builds a business's profile.

We did the Google recovery work at no extra charge.

Watch out for calls about your listing

While the profile was stuck, the owner got a suspicious call about his Google listing. Google says its staff will never ask for payment information over the phone or guarantee a special spot in its products, and it recommends hanging up on calls that pretend to be from Google. Use only Google's own help pages and tools.

What I'd tell any business owner

  1. Don't create a new profile. Recover the one with your history.
  2. Keep your Google login in the business's own account, with the owner as primary owner. Your designer or agency should be a manager.
  3. Request ownership through Google, then give it time.
  4. Change one thing at a time: ownership first, then duplicates, then your address.
  5. Keep your paperwork ready, with the same business name and address everywhere: registration, license, insurance, and photos of branded vehicles or signage.
  6. Write everything down: dates, screenshots and every email from Google.
  7. Use only Google's official channels.

The hardest part of this job wasn't technical. It was patience: waiting out each step and not making things worse in the meantime.

Frequently asked questions

Can I just delete the duplicate?

Only if you're sure which one to remove. Google says removing a profile deletes all its content and its managers. If both profiles are the same business, you can suggest a merge on Google Maps. Google says merged profiles combine their reviews, but review replies may be lost.

How long does the current owner have to answer an ownership request?

Google gives them 3 days. If they don't respond, you may be able to claim the profile, but that option isn't always offered.

How long does an appeal take?

Google says up to 5 business days. Each appeal can be submitted only once, so send everything the first time.

Will Google call me about my profile?

Be careful with any call about your profile. Google says it never asks for payment information over the phone or guarantees a special spot. If in doubt, hang up and contact Google through its help pages.

Want help with yours? Start with our free Local Visibility Checklist, read Google Business Profile vs. Your Website, or request our free Website & SEO Audit. You can also see our SEO & Local Listings services.